Why Replacing Benjamin Netanyahu Will Not Change Israel's Palestinian Policy

Why Replacing Benjamin Netanyahu Will Not Change Israel's Palestinian Policy

Foreign policy pundits love a clean villain. It makes a messy, generational conflict easy to digest over morning coffee.

Read any mainstream wire report about Israeli elections—including the standard Reuters breakdown on what happens if Benjamin Netanyahu loses power—and you will see the same lazy consensus repeated as gospel. The narrative goes like this: Netanyahu is the primary obstacle to a two-state solution, his far-right coalition partners hold the steering wheel, and ousting him will immediately unlock diplomatic breakthroughs, halt settlement expansion, and revive the Oslo framework. Expanding on this topic, you can also read: Stop Falling for the Outrage Over Vivek Ramaswamy’s Campaign Ad.

That analysis is completely backwards.

If you have spent any time tracking Israeli security doctrine, Knesset voting records, or the demographic shifts inside the Israel Defense Forces, you know that Netanyahu is not an aberration. He is a symptom. Believing that swapping out the Prime Minister will magically reverse decades of entrenched security consensus is like thinking a new CEO will turn an oil conglomerate into a solar charity overnight. The institutional machinery simply will not allow it. Analysts at Associated Press have provided expertise on this matter.

The Myth of the Benevolent Centrist

Western journalists routinely frame figures like Benny Gantz, Yair Lapid, or Naftali Bennett as the "moderate" antidotes to Netanyahu’s hardline nationalism. On television panels in Washington and London, they sound polished, pragmatic, and eager to cooperate with international allies.

Look at their actual track records when holding the gavel.

During the 2021–2022 "Change Government"—the most diverse coalition in Israeli history, which explicitly united to unseat Netanyahu and even included an Arab Islamist party—settlement construction in the West Bank did not stop. It actually accelerated. According to data tracked by Peace Now, housing starts in West Bank settlements rose significantly during the Bennett-Lapid tenure compared to the final year of Netanyahu’s previous term.

Why? Because in Israeli politics, the center has moved miles to the right.

  • Yair Lapid speaks warmly about the concept of separation from the Palestinians, yet he refuses to negotiate over the status of Jerusalem or dismantle major settlement blocs.
  • Benny Gantz, a former IDF Chief of Staff, campaigns on security competence, not territorial withdrawal. His platform prioritizes maintaining overarching Israeli military control from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea.
  • Avigdor Lieberman, another frequent anti-Netanyahu coalition partner, literally lives in a West Bank settlement and advocates redrawing borders to strip Arab-Israeli towns of their citizenship.

When analysts ask how a post-Netanyahu government will revive the peace process, they are asking the wrong question entirely. The real question is why anyone still believes an Israeli coalition capable of passing a territorial withdrawal exists in the Knesset. It does not.

Security Doctrine Trumps Prime Ministers

To understand why policy stays static regardless of who sits in the Prime Minister’s Office in Jerusalem, you have to understand how the Israeli defense establishment operates.

Prime ministers come and go. The Shin Bet, Mossad, and the IDF General Staff remain.

Since the collapse of the Camp David summit in 2000, the Second Intifada, and the catastrophic aftermath of the 2005 unilateral disengagement from Gaza—which resulted in Hamas seizing control and firing tens of thousands of rockets into Israeli cities—the Israeli security apparatus reached a near-unanimous conclusion. Unilateral withdrawal without ironclad, verifiable demilitarization is viewed as national suicide.

I have watched foreign diplomats burn through millions of dollars and years of political capital trying to bypass this reality. They treat the conflict as a real estate dispute that just needs a better mediator. They ignore the topographical nightmare of the West Bank. The Judean and Samarian hills overlook Israel’s narrow coastal plain, where roughly 70 percent of the country's population and 80 percent of its industrial capacity sit. From those ridges, an adversary with basic shoulder-fired missiles can shut down Ben Gurion International Airport in minutes.

No Israeli prime minister—left, center, or right—will hand over security control of the Jordan Valley or the West Bank hilltops to a Palestinian Authority that cannot even police Jenin or Nablus.

The Collapse of the Palestinian Partner

Mainstream coverage loves to dissect Israeli coalition math while treating Palestinian leadership as a static, ready-and-waiting peace partner. That is journalistic malpractice.

Any incoming Israeli leader faces a fractured, deeply unpopular Palestinian political system. Mahmoud Abbas and the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah suffer from abysmal approval ratings, endemic corruption, and a looming succession crisis. In Gaza, Hamas remains dedicated to Israel's destruction, even when degraded militarily.

If a centrist prime minister took office tomorrow and offered sweeping territorial concessions, who would sign the deal? Who would enforce it? If the Palestinian Authority collapses the day after an agreement is inked, Hamas or Iranian-backed militias fill the vacuum. Every Israeli voter knows this. After October 7, the electorate's tolerance for security gambles dropped to absolute zero.

What Actually Changes Without Netanyahu

Dismissing the fantasy of an immediate two-state revival does not mean a Netanyahu loss changes nothing. It changes the packaging, the friction, and the tactical execution—and those nuances matter enormously if you are tracking regional stability.

1. The End of Deliberate Diplomatic Sabotage

Netanyahu thrives on political friction with Democratic administrations in Washington. Picking public fights with the White House plays well with his domestic base, proving he is the only leader tough enough to stand up to American pressure. A centrist coalition led by someone like Gantz or Lapid would immediately stop weaponizing the US-Israel relationship for domestic campaign ads. You would see warmer rhetoric, smoother weapons transfers, and closer coordination on regional containment against Iran.

2. Sideling the Messianic Far-Right

The biggest tangible shift would be the removal of ultranationalist ministers like Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich from positions of institutional power. Under Netanyahu, these figures gained control over the police, West Bank civil administration, and settlement budgets. They actively use administrative tools to starve the Palestinian Authority of tax revenues and greenlight unauthorized outposts.

A post-Netanyahu government would cut off that institutional oxygen. They would likely resume transferring cleared tax revenues to Ramallah to prevent the Palestinian Authority from collapsing—not out of ideological love for Palestinian statehood, but because the IDF does not want to take over municipal garbage collection and policing for three million people in the West Bank.

3. Reopening the Saudi Normalization Track

Riyadh wants a defense pact with Washington and civilian nuclear cooperation, and the price of admission includes a credible diplomatic horizon for the Palestinians. Netanyahu cannot pay that price because his current coalition partners will bolt and collapse his government the second he utters the words "Palestinian state."

A centrist prime minister has the political room to offer Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman the diplomatic language he needs—promises of a freeze on isolated outpost expansion, economic packages for the West Bank, and non-binding commitments to future talks—to get a normalization deal across the finish line.

The Blind Spot in the Contrarian Argument

Admitting the limits of my own thesis is necessary here. Structural determinism has a blind spot: black swan events and generational trauma.

Historically, major shifts in Israeli policy rarely happen because of gradual ideological evolution; they happen because of profound shocks. Menachem Begin, a lifelong revisionist hawk, returned the entire Sinai Peninsula to Egypt after the trauma of the 1973 Yom Kippur War. Yitzhak Rabin, the military commander who ordered troops to break the bones of protesters during the First Intifada, shook Yasser Arafat’s hand on the White House lawn when he realized military force alone could not pacify the territories.

It is possible—though unlikely in the short term—that the sheer scale of the post-October 7 trauma eventually forces a total realignment of Israeli politics, creating space for a leader willing to take radical risks in exchange for a regional security architecture backed by the United States and Gulf Arab states. Betting on that outcome, however, is pure speculation.

How to Actually Read Israeli Politics

If you want to stop getting blindsided by Middle East coverage, stop reading headlines about who is winning or losing the prime minister’s chair. Track the structural indicators instead.

  1. Watch the Knesset’s 61-seat math, not the top of the ticket. In Israel’s proportional representation system, no party ever wins an outright majority. Look at the kingmakers. As long as religious Zionist and ultra-Orthodox parties hold the balance of power, territorial compromise is mathematically dead.
  2. Follow the IDF’s operational posture, not diplomatic speeches. When the military expands buffer zones, builds permanent paved roads inside Gaza, or conducts nightly raids in Area A of the West Bank, that is the real policy. Speeches at the United Nations are just theater.
  3. Monitor the Palestinian Authority's solvency. The most immediate threat to the status quo is not a peace treaty; it is the financial and security collapse of Ramallah, which would force Israel into full military reoccupation by default.

Reuters and the rest of the mainstream press will continue to sell the story that Israel’s Palestinian policy hinges on the political survival of one man. It makes for great drama and terrible forecasting.

Netanyahu did not create the deadlock, and his exit will not break it. Until the underlying security equation changes on the ground, changing the nameplate on the Prime Minister’s door is just rearranging deck chairs on a battleship.

AY

Aaliyah Young

With a passion for uncovering the truth, Aaliyah Young has spent years reporting on complex issues across business, technology, and global affairs.